Feminisation Of The Church

Coming to my present congregation in the heart of one of Glasgow’s most deprived parishes I was astounded by its composition. There was hardly a man in the congregation. Never before had I encountered such a gender imbalance. This was I believe a result of many years of that neo-Protestant progressive preaching which is an engine of the feminisation of the Church.

By that I don’t mean women ministers, Anglican priestesses, girl bishops or even lady popes. It is the presentation of the gospel and the biblical message which have been feminised. The face and voice of the Church has altered and this has brought alteration in the composition of the body.

We live in a Manichean age where certain virtues and characteristics are deemed feminine and others masculine. This is generally held to be the case from academic articles to the pop psychology of the men are from Mars women from Venus variety. Progressives generally, and ecclesiastics in particular, value those characteristics deemed feminine and sideline or even denigrate those deemed masculine.This can be helpful if for instance it leads to more co-operation and less competition within the Church. Unfortunately it has also led to an eclipse of the more forthright in the Church.

Such virtues as love, forgiveness and service are rightly emphasised but, however, have been shorn of their strength and cutting edge. Love has come to be the unhesitating acceptance of any person or stance, as it wouldn’t be loving to suggest certain behaviour is sin. Forgiveness is blanket and automatic and totally divorced from repentance. Service has become a servility whereby Christians allow anyone to walk all over them.

There are very few new men in Possilpark where I live. Our guys on the whole don’t put a high priority on getting in touch with their feminine side. Can you really imagine Rab C Nesbit and Inspector Burke from Taggart swapping recipes for involtini al proscutio? Our guys are more at home playing pitch and toss than backgammon.

It is inevitable that there will be a cultural emphasis on the interpretation and presentation of the gospel. The ancient Norsemen when first converted saw the crucifixion as Jesus climbing on to His throne and then entering the tomb where He did battle with the evil one only to emerge victorious from the fight three days later. A Jesus who was a bit like them. Today’s Western progressives see Jesus as a well meaning victim who preached blanket sentimentality. A Jesus who is a bit like them.

The presentation of the gospel has to challenge the surrounding culture, but when the presentation of the gospel runs completely counter to the prevailing culture we find ourselves in difficulty. We can see the results of this today when in the church the few men around are usually seen in the pulpits preaching to mainly empty pews with a scattering of women.

The present understanding of becoming part of the Church is usually seen as a progression of Belonging, Behaving and Believing. A person is drawn into the congregation usually through existing friendships, there she finds herself beginning to take on new patterns of behaviour due to the influence of her new environment and finally she progresses to believe what is taught within the congregation.

Although I have only experiential evidence I tend to think that with men the order is different. According to my observation with men it is Behaviour, Believing and Belonging. It is first of all the challenge to behaviour which confronts a man, and when he finds he cannot change his behaviour on his own he is driven to Christ, and it is after coming to belief that he throws in his lot with Christ’s people and comes to belong.

The great advantage in this is that progressive congregations will die. I freely admit to being a bit of a Neanderthal but no matter what progressives tell us I really don’t think a wimpy Jesus attracts many women. Reality is hard and needs to be confronted with strength, and women are, I believe, much more realistic and down to earth than men the eternal romantics.

Advertisements

About Campbell

Now retired but once upon a time a parish minister in Glasgow, before that the South West and initially the Black Isle. Been a prison chaplain and lecturer. Still am constantly bemused by the weird world around me.
This entry was posted in Church and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Feminisation Of The Church

  1. John James says:

    The 3 ‘B’s’ have been on my mind a fair bit lately and the feminisation of the church has been a particular interest for about a decade.

    My own observations are that adult men do tend to come to the church in the manner you described. I would, however, suggest that it is a Belief, Behaviour, Belonging progression you are describing. It isn’t the change of behaviour which is the start of the process, but the change of belief of what behaviour is acceptable or helpful, and why, which then leads to a change in behaviour and eventually to seek a brotherhood of like-minded people.

    Another aspect which I suspect may be important is that the divide along gender lines is more pronounced in older, urban demographics. The Belong, Behave, Believe mantra is quite successful with younger males, perhaps because of that age group’s existing desire to find interest communities where they can ‘fit in’. For more rural communities it may be that belonging to the community in general comes first with the church being a part of that community.

  2. malcolm says:

    to me its a poverty thing were there is no work, no prospects, what do they do, go to the pub watch the football and mention that you are going to the church and it all goes silent for a moment then a burst of laughter . if you manage to get away from that then you start to see whats going on around you then you start to think a bit straighter but most men seem to be in that rut and cant seem to change saying that i have noticed that a lot of men are tired of this, and want a change in there drinkin habits time will tell and the football is rubbish any way .

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s